A Springfield, Ohio, Trump supporter who blamed her Haitian neighbors for stealing her cat recently discovered that the missing pet had been hiding in her basement the entire time.

The part-time rabbi at the only synagogue in Springfield, Ohio, told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency that Haitian migrants are disenfranchising the town’s citizens, claiming that two members of his congregation had been “forced to move” out of an apartment complex and injured in a car accident because of the influx.